Once someone knows of my wonderful ability to get lost it can become a defining characteristic.
During my college years I was a bridesmaid in a wedding held in a city slightly South East of Columbus. It was a 30 mile drive and I attempted to go by myself to the rehearsal. After all, I had made it to the bridal shower without help from anyone. (But I could be mistaken – it’s entirely possible the bride picked me up to make sure I’d be there!) In high school and college I didn’t own a car. I only drove the family station wagon in the city. On this particular trip the freeway signs confused me.  Lost and anxious, I pulled over and used a pay phone to tell them I was late. (This was before cell phones were everywhere and the best quality movie format you could find was a laser disc.) The pay phone was located 55 miles North West of the rehearsal. I had gone 23 miles in the opposite direction of where I needed to be!  In my absence I was nicknamed “Miss Plain City 1992” because that was where I called from.Â
I write “lost” too. It’s difficult for me to use outlines or have a real sense of structure when I tackle a short story. When lost while driving I get anxious. I worry about how late I’ll be, how long it will take me to get righted, and how much fun I may be missing. When writing while lost it is an entirely different experience.  My words meander across the pages. I’m confident I’ll get to where I need to go. There is no time limit on when I have to get there. It’s so much easier to enjoy the ride.
The good thing about meandering or getting lost is that there’s always the edit stage to cut out any side trips that get the reader totally lost.
The editing stage is a wonderful part of the writing process. It can definitely reroute the trip to a more direct path.
First, you need to ask for a GPS navigation system next Christmas! 😉
As for getting lost during the first draft of any story, it can sometimes take you to new and wonderful places. You might develop a new scene that provides unexpected depth for a character and intertwines them into the story in a more complete way. Of course, editing is always important. Like Helen said, the reader will not enjoy getting lost.